Skip to main content
A Clear Direction
rss feedour twitterour facebook page linkdin
Financial Advisor Brisbane - AdviserScott Keefer - A Clear DirectionBuilding Investment PortfoliosPortfolio Management ServiceUpdated ContentContact Us - Brisbane Financial Planning
A Clear Direction Financial Planning logo
 Research Based Approach 
 Active Fund Managers Underperform 

Our approach:

The research overwhelmingly has shown that active investment managers do not consistently outperform the market.  We therefore choose an asset class approach to choosing investments using index style investments. 


The research:

Measuring the True Cost of Active Management by Mutual Funds

Journal of Investment Management

Ross M. Miller

2007, Vol. 5, No. 1: pp29-49


What the paper says: Even the average mutual fund, which ostensibly provides only active management, will have over 90% of the variance in its returns explained by its benchmark index.


In the author's own words: "funds engaging in closet or shadow indexing charge their investors for active management while providing them with little more than an indexed investment."


On Persistence in Mutual Fund Performance

The Journal of Finance

Mark M. Cahart

March 1997, Vol. LII, No. 1: 57-82


What the paper says: There is no evidence that choosing a managed fund that had outperformed in the past would provide above average returns into the future.


In the author's own words: "The results do not support the existence of skilled or informed mutual fund portfolio managers."


Returns From Investing in Australian Equity Superannuation Funds, 1991-1999

Services Industry Journal

Michael Drew and Jon Stanford (University of Queensland)

September 2003, Vol. 23, Issue 4: 12 - 24


What the paper says:  Rather than add value for investors, the fund managers in the superannuation industry ended up performing so poorly that they actually underperformed the average index return by a significant margin.


In the author's own words: "as an industry, investment managers destroyed value for superannuation investors for the period 1991 through 1999, under-performing passive portfolio returns by 2.80-4.00 per cent per annum on a risk-unadjusted basis'".

The next page in the research story - Diversification
Scott Francis' articles in the Eureka Report 

Plan Well, Invest Well, Live Well! Financial advice providing a clear direction

A Clear Direction Financial Planning and Portfolio Management ABN 85 147 572 870

Level 19
10 Eagle Street
Brisbane QLD Australia
Ph: (07) 3303 0269

Authorised Representative (398444) and Credit Representative (403292) of FYG Planners Pty Ltd AFSL/ACL 224 543.

ASIC - Financial Advisers Register

All content of this website is copyright © A Clear Direction Financial Planning Pty Ltd, 2017

FYG Planners Pty Ltd & A Clear Direction Financial Planning Privacy Policy